Skip to content

Before the crisis breaks

“It was not mine.” Ed Sheeran is left on his own — but can reputation be handed to a promoter?

Macklemore was dropped from the tour. Then every announced support act withdrew, and Beoga, who played during part of Sheeran’s own set, also pulled out. Yet the media very quickly stopped telling the story as the promoter’s crisis. This is a case about the difference between formal authorship of a decision and reputational responsibility for its consequences.

Status as verified: 19 September 2026, morning. The situation is developing.

Sometimes a crisis begins with a decision you made yourself.

This one is more interesting.

Because Ed Sheeran maintains that he did not make the most important decision.

After Macklemore’s sets at the MetLife Stadium concerts, some of the owners of venues due to host upcoming shows objected to the rapper remaining on the tour. The promoter, Messina Touring Group, removed him from the subsequent dates. Sheeran later said he had tried to find a solution, but the decision lay with the promoter and the venues.

A few days later, the headlines were no longer mainly about the promoter.

They were about Ed Sheeran.

And this is where the most interesting part of the story begins.

Because reputation has one inconvenient trait:

it does not read contracts.

Two concerts, one conflict and a decision that set off an avalanche

At the MetLife Stadium concerts in early September, Macklemore publicly expressed support for Palestinians, said “Free Palestine” from the stage and performed the protest song “Hind’s Hall”. His sets drew both support and strong opposition. Robert Kraft, owner of Gillette Stadium and founder of an organisation dedicated to combating antisemitism, regarded Macklemore’s statements and past conduct as offensive to the Jewish community; Macklemore himself rejects the charge of antisemitism and presents his position as criticism of Israel’s policies and actions and as a defence of Palestinians.

The promoter then announced that Macklemore would not appear at the remaining concerts.

Ed Sheeran spoke out.

He explained that Macklemore’s contract was with the promoter, not with him, and wrote:

“Macklemore coming off tour was the promoter’s decision, it was not mine.”

He also said he had tried to “build a bridge” between the two sides. By his account, venues for the upcoming dates had signalled that they might pull the shows if Macklemore remained on the line-up.

And formally, he may be right.

Except that formal responsibility and reputational responsibility are not always the same thing.

“It was not mine” does not answer the second question

In reputation management, it is worth separating two things.

First:

who had the formal right to make the decision?

Second:

who had real influence over how it unfolded?

The Associated Press examined exactly this problem. The promoter finances and organises the tour, and a venue can refuse to host a concert, but industry experts also point out that an artist of Sheeran’s standing usually has considerable negotiating power and influence over a venture that bears his own name.

And that is when people stop asking:

“Who signed off on the decision?”

They start asking:

“Who could have done something?”

That is a much harder question.

And one that business knows all too well.

A CEO may not be the one who signs a personnel decision.

An investor may not close the road — the contractor does.

A manufacturer may not make the faulty component — a subcontractor supplies it.

A company may be implementing a regulator’s decision.

But once a matter becomes public, people rarely start with the division of responsibilities.

They look at the name.

At the brand.

At the leader.

At the biggest logo on the poster.

Then Macklemore was no longer the only problem

Had the story ended with the removal of one support act, Sheeran would have had a difficult but contained dispute to manage.

That is not what happened.

Other artists began to withdraw from the tour.

Aaron Rowe.

Finneas.

Lukas Graham.

Beoga.

And here precision matters:

Macklemore was removed. The others left of their own accord.

Reuters reported that the support acts and Sheeran’s backing band had pulled out. AP points out that Beoga were not merely another support act — the band also played during part of Sheeran’s main set.

That changed the meaning of the story completely.

First, we had a conflict:

artist – promoter – stadiums.

Then a second layer emerged:

people inside the project began publicly voting with their feet.

And where reputation is concerned, a stakeholder’s behaviour often sends a stronger message than an official statement.

And then something even more interesting happened: they were leaving, but they did not stop being his people

This is precisely what saves the case from a banal split into heroes and villains.

Some of the artists pulling out stressed, in the same breath, their gratitude to Sheeran and their personal ties with him. Rowe described him as a friend and as someone hugely important to his career.

It is a very human part of the whole story.

You can like someone.

You can be grateful to them.

You can consider them a good person.

And at the same time reach a point where you no longer want to be part of a project run under their name.

This is an important lesson for organisations, too:

loyalty to a person does not oblige you to accept every decision of the project that person represents.

The media found their story. And it is not the promoter’s story

This is probably the most interesting part of the whole crisis from a communications point of view.

Reuters and the Associated Press separate the roles very carefully: Sheeran, the promoter, the stadium owners, Robert Kraft.

But the media framing quickly began to simplify.

Wirtualna Polska asked people from the Polish music industry about responsibility for the situation. Their comments are far more cautious than many online headlines.

Hirek Wrona points out that without knowing the contracts it is hard to judge with any certainty how much real influence Sheeran had.

Bartek Chaciński, however, captured the crux of the reputational problem: it is not known to what extent the artist’s opinion mattered, but it is Sheeran who has suffered the greatest damage to his image.

That is an exceptionally apt observation.

The formal answer is:

“It was not mine”.

The media story is:

“Ed Sheeran is left on his own”.

Between those two sentences lies practically the entire crisis.

Today’s Guardian already describes the situation as a full-blown “culture war” around an artist who spent years building as broad and non-confrontational a brand as possible.

The Wall Street Journal, for its part, presents Sheeran’s case as the problem of the modern “apolitical pop star”: an artist trying to create a musical space outside politics in a world where neutrality, too, is sometimes read as a stance.

That is an important shift.

The crisis was no longer about one support act.

It was now about the very way Ed Sheeran’s brand is built.

Along the way, P!nk illustrates one more mechanism

P!nk is not the central figure in this case, which is precisely why she no longer appears in the final graphic.

Her conduct, however, is an interesting small-scale example of contemporary communication risk.

She first shared someone else’s statement criticising Macklemore. She later clarified her own position, stressing that the reposted words were not her own and that she had not called for the artist to be silenced.

A minor episode, but an important principle:

a repost is a message, too.

Audiences do not always draw the subtle distinction between:

“I wrote”,

“I quoted”,

“I shared”.

This applies to stars.

But just as much to:

CEOs,

directors,

experts,

politicians,

brands.

The first consequences can already be counted — but we need to be careful about what we are actually measuring

According to NME, citing Social Blade data, Sheeran lost more than 200,000 Instagram followers over the following days, while Macklemore gained more than 1.6 million.

These are numbers that look good in a headline.

But on their own they do not prove a lasting collapse in reputation.

Sheeran remains an artist followed by tens of millions of people.

So the far more interesting question is:

is the meaning attached to his brand changing?

There has also been pressure on the ticket market. Business Insider, drawing on Ticketdata figures, reported that resale prices fell at nine of the next ten tour stops; in Philadelphia by 17% in three days and by around 25% within a week.

At the same time, some fans began asking publicly about refunds after the changes to the concert line-ups.

These are already business signals.

But they are still no proof that the Loop Tour is collapsing financially.

Quite the opposite.

The Associated Press notes that, according to Pollstar, Sheeran’s tour was the highest-grossing tour of 2025, averaging more than $7 million in revenue per city.

Keeping a sense of proportion is very important here.

This is a reputational crisis. Not proof that Ed Sheeran’s business is finished.

Did Ed Sheeran sell out a friend for money?

The question all but begs for a tabloid headline.

And that would be a mistake.

We do not know.

We have not heard the private conversations.

We have not seen the full structure of the contracts.

We do not know exactly what options were put to Sheeran, or how far he could have pushed in negotiations without losing more venues.

What we do know is that money was a real piece of the puzzle.

Not just Sheeran’s money.

But also the jobs and incomes of the people who make a major tour happen.

Tickets bought by fans.

Contracts.

Transport.

Technical production.

Stadiums.

Local services.

Sheeran himself spoke of his responsibility to the audience and to the people working on the tour.

That is why the more interesting question is not:

“Did he sell out a friend?”

But rather:

How high a price was he prepared to pay to defend him?

And did the public consider that price high enough?

That is now a question of leadership.

Because Sheeran was trying to protect several things at once

A friendship.

The tour.

The fans.

The people working on the production.

Relationships with stadium owners.

His own vision of a concert as a space kept as far as possible from political disputes.

And his own reputation.

The problem is that not all of these values could be protected at the same time.

That is precisely what distinguishes a genuine crisis of decision from one that a good statement can easily resolve.

Had Sheeran refused to continue the tour without Macklemore, some of the concerts could have been put at risk.

When he accepted the promoter’s decision, other artists left the project.

Had he publicly and clearly taken one side in the political conflict, he would have changed his long-standing positioning.

When he tries to remain neutral, part of the audience interprets even that neutrality.

There is no cost-free solution here.

Neutrality works only for as long as others accept it as neutrality

This is one of the most interesting aspects of the case.

Over the years, Sheeran has built a very broad brand.

Relationships.

Emotions.

Love.

Music.

Closeness to the audience.

Little in the way of aggressive political identification.

The Wall Street Journal notes that the expectations of part of today’s audience — particularly younger fans — increasingly extend to artists taking public positions on important social issues.

This does not mean that an artist is obliged to adopt a particular political line.

It means something else:

a brand does not have full control over how its own silence is interpreted.

The same happens in business.

A company can say:

“we are not taking part in this dispute”.

Its stakeholders may nonetheless read the company’s conduct as taking a position.

The absence of a statement can also become a statement.

The paradox: Macklemore may come out of this crisis with a stronger reputation

Macklemore lost his place on one of the biggest concert tours in the world.

At the same time:

he gained enormous visibility,

his follower count shot up,

his songs drew a fresh wave of interest,

and the dispute carried his position into the global media.

Reuters has even reported on a mural of the rapper painted in Gaza as a tribute to his public stance.

Whatever one thinks of the political conflict itself, from a reputational point of view this is extremely interesting.

You can lose the contract and win the narrative.

Just as you can keep the project — and pay for it with part of your reputational capital.

Is this the end of Ed Sheeran’s career?

No.

As of today, there are no solid grounds for writing that ending.

Concerts have not been cancelled wholesale.

Sheeran is still one of the most commercially successful artists in the world.

On 19 September he is due back on stage in Philadelphia — for the first time since the crisis escalated. Ahead of the concert, AP reported that the official website had not yet named any replacement support acts, and that a protest was planned outside the stadium.

So today this is not the story of:

“the end of Ed Sheeran”.

It is, however, a serious test of part of his reputation.

And an unusual one.

It is not about talent.

It is not about the quality of the music.

It is not about a personal scandal.

It is about the question:

who, really, is the man behind the Ed Sheeran brand when a truly costly decision comes along?

And that question may matter more than a temporary outflow of followers.

200,000 followers is not the most important number

What will matter most is something harder to measure.

What will someone think who has for years regarded Sheeran as:

loyal,

down-to-earth,

likeable,

unspoilt by success,

a good mate?

If the answer is:

“He found himself in a situation with no good way out and tried to resolve it” —

the crisis may leave his deeper reputation intact.

If, however, it is:

“When values started to come at a price, business came first” —

the problem will be far more serious.

Because losing a follower is a metric.

Losing the meaning attached to a brand is a change in reputation.

What should Ed Sheeran do now?

I do not think he needs another long explanation of who formally made the decision.

That has already been said.

In communication terms, it would be far stronger to move from the language of:

“I am not responsible for this decision”

to:

“I take responsibility for my part in what happens now”.

He does not have to claim that he removed Macklemore himself.

If he did not, he should not.

But he can say:

I did not make this decision. But it happened on a tour that bears my name. That is why I am accountable for what I do next.

That is the fundamental difference.

Between:

managing blame

and

managing reputation.

Takeaway for the board

This story is not primarily about music at all.

It is about a situation that happens in organisations all the time.

The board says:

“the regulator requires it”.

The CEO:

“the lawyers recommended it”.

The investor:

“the contractor decided”.

Head office:

“the decision was made in another market”.

All of these statements may be true.

But stakeholders later ask different questions:

Did you have influence?

How did you use it?

What did you do when you saw the consequences?

The hardest reputational crises do not always begin when a leader has done something wrong.

Sometimes they begin when the leader:

did not control the whole decision, but had influence;

was not the formal owner of the problem, but their name stood for the venture;

did not want to take sides, but not choosing was interpreted too;

tried to protect many values that could not all be saved at once.

You can delegate logistics.

You can delegate the contract.

You can delegate an operational decision.

Reputation is much harder to delegate.

Because when our name is in the largest type on the poster, people rarely start with the small print of the contract.

They start with the question:

“What did you do when you saw what was happening?”

Sources — as of 19 September 2026

First published in Polish on LinkedIn, 19 September 2026.

More analyses